"Marketing Mary, 42, CMO at a mid-sized company, values data, hates silos." Most people who have worked with personas know this kind of description. But ask yourself: who actually made the decision the last time a customer bought your product? Was it really Mary, alone? The answer is almost always no.
Personas are an inheritance from B2C marketing, where one person makes one decision. In B2B, that doesn't hold. Gartner's researchSourceGartner: The B2B Buying JourneyGartner for SalesGartner describes the typical buying group for a complex B2B solution as involving 6-10 decision-makers.View source ↗ on B2B buying shows that a typical buying group - a buying committee - involves 6-10 decision-makers, each with their own mandate, their own risk, and their own answer to the question "what happens to my career if this goes wrong?"
A persona typically captures the role marketing talks to most - the user or the technical evaluator. It rarely captures the economic decision-maker, almost never procurement and legal, and not at all the dynamics between them: who needs to be convinced by whom, and in what order. The result is content that speaks to one person in the room and is invisible to the others who also have to say yes.
01Map the Roles, Not the People
Instead of one composite persona, I work with six roles that recur in most B2B buying groups. For each role, the decisive question isn't what they want, but what they fear:
The economic decision-maker
Owns the budget and carries the ultimate risk. Fears having to explain a failed project to the executive team and the board a year later.
The champion
The internal advocate who found you and now has to sell the solution internally. Needs ammunition rather than product information: customer cases, ROI calculations, and references that can be passed on.
The technical evaluator
Assesses whether the solution works, can be integrated, and can scale. Doesn't want to be blamed if something breaks, and trusts documentation more than marketing language.
The end user
Has to live with the solution day to day. Often the most honest voice in the room, but rarely the one with veto power.
Procurement and legal
Can stop a deal for reasons that have nothing to do with the product's value: contract terms, data processing, and vendor risk.
The sceptic
Present in almost every buying group, often driven by a tendency to stick with the familiar or by a bad experience with a previous vendor.
02Group Psychology Is Different From Individual Psychology
Much of what is written about B2B sales psychology leans on Robert Cialdini's principles of persuasionSourceRobert B. Cialdini: Pre-SuasionSimon & Schuster, 2016Here Cialdini adds unity as the seventh principle of persuasion, alongside the six from "Influence".View source ↗ - seven in total since he added unity to the original six in 2016. They explain how one person is persuaded. A buying group is something else: a group of people, each trying to avoid personal risk while having to reach agreement.
Loss Aversion Outweighs Promises of Gain
Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky's researchSourceDaniel Kahneman & Amos Tversky: Prospect Theory: An Analysis of Decision under RiskEconometrica, 47(2), 1979The paper that describes loss aversion: a loss weighs psychologically heavier than an equivalent gain.View source ↗ on loss aversion shows that a loss weighs psychologically heavier than an equivalent gain. In B2B the imbalance is amplified, because the decision-maker rarely reaps the gain personally but bears the full personal risk. A sales message that is only about gain therefore underestimates how much fear needs to be neutralised. Build a risk-reduction argument for every gain claim: references, guarantees, low-commitment pilots, and open failure scenarios ("here's what happens if it doesn't work, and here's how we handle it").
The Person Who Says No Wins by Default
It takes far less energy to say "let's wait" than "let's do it". The status quo is always the easiest agreement to reach, so a single sceptical voice can stop a purchase even if the rest of the group is positive. Overlook the sceptic, and you often lose the deal late for reasons that were never said out loud. So ask the champion directly: "Who on your side will be most sceptical of this, and what do they need to see to feel confident?" It's an uncomfortable question, but it surfaces the real blocker in time.
Social Proof - But the Right Kind
Generic social proof ("hundreds of satisfied customers") lands weakly in larger B2B purchases, because it doesn't touch the specific risk. The strongest form reads: "Someone like me, in a similar situation, made the same decision and avoided exactly the problem I'm afraid of." One customer case that answers the objection no one has dared say out loud is stronger than a long list of logos.
Order Matters More Than Arguments
Convince the champion and the technical evaluator first, and they can carry the argument to the economic decision-maker with credibility you can never achieve from the outside. Go straight to the budget owner, and you lack the internal backing that makes the message credible when the rest of the group is consulted.
03Putting It Into Practice
For each role, note the primary fear, the preferred form of proof (customer case, numbers, reference, or technical documentation), and the channels the role actually uses. A CFO is unlikely to read your blog, and a technical evaluator rarely sees your LinkedIn ads.
The roles tell you what each person needs answered. Behavioural models tell you how the answer should be delivered. Many people know them from sales training, and they can easily be layered on top of the role map:
Emotional Customer Types
Jannie Ilum Gade's Danish modelSourceJannie Ilum Gade (ILUM/GADE ApS): Emotionelle Kundetyper®kundetyper.dkA Danish model that groups customers by their buying mood - the emotion driving the purchase decision - in four colours: red, yellow, blue and green.View source ↗ groups customers by their buying mood, the emotion driving the purchase decision, in four colours: red seeks stimulation and renewal, yellow balance and belonging, blue momentum, and green security. The point is that it is the situation and the emotion in the purchase, not the personality, that determines how the message should be put together. A CFO who has to avoid a specific risk is green in that purchase and must be met with security, even if they are decisive day to day.
Insights Discovery
Insights DiscoverySourceInsights Learning & Development: Insights Discovery - de fire farveenergierInsightsA model based on Jungian psychology that describes preferences through four colour energies: Fiery Red, Sunshine Yellow, Earth Green and Cool Blue.View source ↗ is based on Carl Jung's psychological types and uses four colour energies to describe how people prefer to communicate and make decisions: from the direct and results-driven to the analytical and thorough.
Social Styles
David Merrill and Roger Reid's modelSourceDavid W. Merrill & Roger H. Reid: Personal Styles & Effective PerformanceChilton (i dag CRC Press/Routledge), 1981The book behind the Social Styles model with four styles: Driving, Expressive, Amiable and Analytical.View source ↗ places people by how assertive and how emotionally expressive they are: Driving, Expressive, Amiable and Analytical. It was developed for sales and management and is still used in sales training.
None of the models can predict what a specific person will decide, and the research behind them is debated. Use them as a shared language for how you adapt tone and format, not as a truth about the individual. The role determines what needs convincing. The type helps with how.
Then build a content map for the buying group: a simple spreadsheet showing what material you have for each role, and where the gaps are. Most companies discover that the majority of their content speaks to one or two roles. Finally, build the sequence into the sales process: who needs to be convinced first in order to advocate to the next, and what should they bring with them? When marketing and sales share the map, it becomes a shared working tool.
It does not require a new system. Most CRMs already have a field for a contact's role in the purchase, and if you use it consistently, you can see for each deal which roles you have been in dialogue with and which are missing. A content map in a spreadsheet and a fixed place for the roles in the CRM are enough to get started.
The takeaway
The real barrier to most good B2B purchases isn't a lack of belief in the value, but unaddressed personal and organisational risk. Personas were never wrong as a concept - they were built for a market where one person decides. Design your content and sales process around the fact that a B2B decision is a negotiated outcome, and you help the buying group make the decision they already know is right but are afraid to stand alone with.