da
AdvisoryCasesInsightsAboutBook a Call
MethodologiesMethodology·5 min read·3 sections

Positioning in Competitive B2B Markets

A single unique selling point does not solve positioning in a market where every competitor says the same thing. Here is how to use alternatives, target customers and category choice to become the obvious choice.

Read five competitors' "about us" pages in a competitive B2B market and you find almost the same promises: innovative, customer-focused, market-leading. Not because the companies lack anything that sets them apart. Most have it. It is because they try to fit the whole difference into one sentence, in a market that has become too complex for that.

Positioning is not about finding the right adjective. It is about controlling the context in which the customer judges you. That is the core of the approach April Dunford describes in her book SourceApril Dunford: Obviously AwesomeAmbient Press, 2019A book on positioning that starts from the context and alternatives the customer compares against.View source ↗, which the model here builds on in simplified form.

01Why a Single Selling Point Is Not Enough

The idea of a single Unique Selling Proposition comes from adman SourceRosser Reeves: Reality in AdvertisingAlfred A. Knopf, 1961The book in which adman Rosser Reeves sets out the Unique Selling Proposition: one clear promise that competitors cannot or do not offer. The link goes to the Advertising Hall of Fame page on Reeves.View source ↗ in the 1960s. It assumes a market with few, clearly different players, where the customer knows the category and simply has to choose. Most B2B markets do not look like that today. Categories overlap, and the customer often does not know what you should be compared with. Are you a marketing automation tool, a CRM extension or an analytics platform? The result is that the customer compares you with the wrong competitor or does not understand why you are relevant at all.

02The Five Building Blocks

01

The alternatives

What would the customer do without you? Not only the obvious competitors, but also carrying on as they do today or solving the problem in a completely different way. Many positioning exercises fail here because they overlook that "we do what we always do" is often the biggest competitor.

02

What only you have

What do you have that the alternatives do not, described concretely and verifiably rather than in marketing language? This is where the old idea of a unique selling point lives on, but as one building block out of five.

03

The value

What business value does what only you have create for the customer? It is the bridge between "we have this" and "this is why it matters", and the step many skip by going straight from feature to promise.

04

The target customers

Who sees that value most clearly? Not everyone who could buy, but those who get the most out of what you do best. The sharper that group is described, the easier the rest of the work.

05

The category

Which category do you choose to be judged in? It is a deliberate strategic choice, not a description. Call yourselves "the best CRM" and you are measured against the biggest players on their terms. Choose a category where your strengths are the natural starting point, and you become the reference.

03How to Work With It

Imagine a software company competing as "yet another project management tool" against giants with far bigger budgets. It cannot win that fight on features or volume. If it positions itself instead as project management for subcontractors in construction, it goes from competing with everything to being the obvious choice for one group. Same product, a completely different competitive situation.

It takes courage, because you give up part of the market to own another part completely. Many leadership teams hesitate, because it feels like limiting the potential. In practice, trying to be relevant to everyone makes you invisible to most. Be careful about inventing an entirely new category, though. It requires you to teach the market what it is, and that is expensive. It is often better to choose a known category and a sharp niche within it.

  1. 1

    Step 1

    Map the alternatives broadly.

    Include carrying on as you do today and solving the problem in a completely different way.

  2. 2

    Step 2

    Test what only you have.

    Write down every claim and ask: could a competitor say exactly the same and be believed? If so, it is not unique.

  3. 3

    Step 3

    Build the bridge to value.

    Show the path from attribute to business value with concrete examples and evidence, not abstract promises.

  4. 4

    Step 4

    Choose target customers and category deliberately.

    Describe those who see the value most clearly, and choose the category where your strengths make you the obvious choice.

Do you need to buy anything to get started? No. What it takes is the right people in the same room: leadership, sales and the people who deliver to customers, ideally with an honest conversation with some of your best customers about why they chose you and what else they considered. Once the positioning is in place, you could consider turning it into core values and messages, e.g. with the Story Wheel, so it is also used in content and sales.

The takeaway

Positioning is not an exercise done once and forgotten. It is the foundation that content, sales training and product priorities should refer back to. Without that foundation, innovative and customer-focused is all that is left to say, and the rest of the market already says it.

Want to work with this?

Let's talk about your situation.

Book an introductory conversation